original sound for musicians with Windows 11

[JosefineR]

Hello
Since I have my new computer with windows 11, the setting "original sound for musicians" in zooms does not work anymore. In detail, we can hear each other speak but the music sounds seem to be submitted by my laptop. Despite that I have the mode "original sound for musicians" switched on, my music teacher cannot hear me play. I read that some others experienced the same problem but none of the suggested trouble shootings helped so far. Interestingly, with Skype the sound is worse in general, but the music is transmitted, so I would not suspect a problem with my laptop in general but rather problem between zoom and windows 11....

Anyone who can help with that?
Best and grateful for any input!

Josefine

[janets]

Exact same issue.  I've been looking for answers thru Windows11 as well as Zoom.  Microsoft says to contact Zoom; Zoom support response was 'we can't help you.'  

[janets]

Finally found solution -- not in Zoom settings but on laptop (I have an LG) side.   Sound setting defaults under Windows 11 changed from those in Windows 10 which ended up overriding Zoom settings.  Specifics are probably different depending on laptop/sound software but I'd suggest probing that side.  At least it worked for me. 

[MelLewis]

Can you elaborate on how you changed the settings on your laptop. I have tried to change my audio settings on my Hp but don’t really know what they should be 

[janets]

Unfortunately I can't remember specific change as it was somewhat of an iterative process.  Perhaps someone with Windows sound settings expertise can chime in.

[CarlaA]

Hi @JosefineR @janets , welcome to the Zoom Community and thank you for your contributions!

When you are connected to the meeting audio with the Computer Audio option, can you please also confirm that in the top-left hand corner of the meeting window, the status of the Original Sound for Musicians feature is on?

If it is not, please click the Original Sound for Musicians button to toggle this on.
A notification will appear, indicating if the feature is currently enabled or not.

Note: If you enable Original Sound for Musician in a meeting, all noise suppression is disabled. If you disable Original Sound for Musicians, the client reverts to the noise suppression setting that you chose in client settings, meaning it could be Auto / Low / Med / High.

Please let me know if the issue persists even when it is enabled in your settings and also toggled on in your meeting. Thank you!

Carla,
Zoom Community Team

[JosefineR]

Dear Zoom Team

Yes, the sign appears in the upper right corner and the note for switching it on appeard. The problem nevertheless persists. Please note, that I was using this setting for years now and only have problems with my new computer. That is why I assume it is likely an incompatibility between Zoom and Windows 11. Please let me know if you have other suggestions.

Best

Josefine

[IraTechHead]

We have the same issue making it difficult to hear.  This was not a problem until about four to six months ago. We use two laptops to share our services and thought it was only the new Windows 11 laptop, but noticed the older Windows 10 was doing the same thing.  If the volume of the singer rises, it sounds like AGC is enabled the volume almost mutes. On the other hand if people are singing and turn from facing the mic, the mic seems to fully mute.  Only once could I say the the Original Sound seemed to work right after enabling it as I could hear background noise, but that went away minutes later leaving back to muted audio. Adding and external mic had no effect.  Zoom must an idea as to a fix.

[cheriechoo]

Enable original sound is on. So??

Zoom for piano lessons  has been working for years and suddenly I cannot hear the piano for several of my students.

Is it change in operating system?  PC or Mac?

Help!!!

[JudgeJoyce]

I have the same problem. My teacher can’t hear me play

[storyhub]

I am an electrical engineer with focus in broadcasting and audio engineering. I would like to know if you would be willing to accept one-on-one assistance via Zoom? I have Zoom running on Windows 11 and use original sound all the time and it works fine for me. I do Zoom sessions several times a week that include musical content.

[JudgeJoyce]

I would love that!  What do you charge and how do we arrange it. Right now and until 2/29 I am in Hawaii. 

[DPL]

I am a fitness instructor and I have been teaching on Zoom since 2020. My livelihood relies on being able to play music on Zoom and teach classes such as Zumba and dance. Right now I’m having static when I talk online and when I share a screen. In addition, I know I will eventually need a new computer and I know there are noise cancellation problems with Windows 11 and Zoom when playing music. Is there a way I can talk to you about this because it seems like a lot of people are having problems with this but it seems like there’s no clear cut answer. Thank you so much 

[MelLewis]

Are you offering help with this issue? I am also in the same boat. My zoom settings original sound for musicians is set, and no one can hear the bell sound coming through in meetings anymore. How to remedy this, and Zoom not responding to issue.

Thanks Mel

[JudgeJoyce]

I have the same problem, and I have had it on two different HP computers. In every instance, original sound for musicians is on, but my teacher, who is the host can hear me speak, but cannot hear me play the piano. I’m totally disgusted. Is there a solution? 

[yunmi23]

Since you have an HP search for “Bang & Olufsen“ and make sure none of the setting are supressing background sounds. Good luck!

[Paresh]

Tried everything you mentioned. Still, the problem is there. I am not able to take any of my music lessons online due to this issue.

[storyhub]

This issue is more complex than it appears on the surface. Would you like one-on-one engineering assistance via Zoom? I am a broadcast and A/V engineer and specialize in audio engineering. If so let me know and I can arrange to assist you.

[MelLewis]

I would like assistance.... but seems like there is no fix to this issue. 

Are you confident you can fix? and if unable to is there a fee?

[JudgeJoyce]

I had original sound for musicians turned on. The problem has never resolved. And we have seitched to FaceTime!

[IraTechHead]

We have the exact problem.  Our congregation replaced the main laptop used during services and I thought it was Windows 11 that was on the new laptop and set it to Original Sound without improvement. I even added an external mic, still poor with "muddy" sound as Zoom seems to mute the vocals. I was sure it was Windows 11, but we noticed on the second laptop which Windows 10 and had been working very well up until the last few months, now as the singer raises her singing voice the mike almost completely mutes.  Setting this laptop to Original Sound has no affect.  When I set Original Sound while using the cell phone works as expected and substantially improves the sound, but comparing enabling Original Sound on the laptops seems to produce no detectable change.  There is something wrong with Zoom and it's interaction with Windows. This changed for us about 4 or 6 months ago.

[storyhub]

Please note that "original sound" must be activated everytime you start a new session and everytime you change a mic choice. Make sure that the upper left corner of the Zoom window says that original sound is on (if not click on it to turn it on) - do not assume that because you set it during the last session that it was remembered for the current session.

[couth]

Go down blow and read RN, Zoom moderator. I clicked Sund Panel and disabled Speaker and microphone Audio enhancements. Also disable to communication setting to Do nothing then now ZOOM pick up my piano sound.  My Samsung Galaxy book with Windows 11 was fine, but my new LG Gram computer with Windows 11 completely blocks my piano sound. I deleted the LG smart assistant as Zoom mentioned, but it still blocks piano sounds. I had to switch back to my old computer during the piano lesson. An external microphone didn't solve the problem. 

[Trishv]

We are having the same problem. Has anyone had a solution?

[CarlaA]

Hi everyone!

can you please confirm that you are on the most recent version of the Zoom app? Here's how: https://support.zoom.us/hc/en-us/articles/201362233-Updating-Zoom-to-the-latest-version

After updating the Zoom application, please ensure that the Original Sound for Musicians setting is turned on:
 

1. Sign in to the Zoom desktop client.
2. Click the Audio settings.
3. Enable the Original Sounds for Musicians
4. Make sure to uncheck the "Automatically adjust microphone volume" and set it to max gauge or enough volume level of the Microphone.
5. Join or start a meeting.
6. Connect to meeting audio with the Computer Audio option.
   In the top-left corner of the meeting window, the current status of the Original Sound for Musicians feature is indicated.
7. Click the Original Sound for Musicians button to toggle this ON.
8. Check again if the problem persists.

Please confirm that you have updated the app and turned on the Original Sound setting by replying to this thread. Thank you!

Carla,
Zoom Community Team

[JudgeJoyce]

I have done everything you listed on 2 different HP comuters. Still my piano teacher cannot hear me play but can hear me talk’

[Trishv]

We are on the current app and have also designated Original Sound for Musicians and that did not resolve the problem or dent it in any way.

Trish

[CarlaA]

Hi @Trishv , thank you for the update! We are having our engineers take a closer look at this issue.  I will update you as soon as I can. 

[Trishv]

Thanks for your responsiveness, Carla!

[CarlaA]

Hi @Trishv , would you be able to test something for me? can you please uninstall “MaxxAudio“ or “Bang & Olufsen“ from your device and retest?

[JosefineR]

Dear Carla
At least on my computer I checked and its not installed at all, so I cannat uninstall. I am happy to try other ideas or suggestions.

[Trishv]

Carla, unfortunately the laptop is at the church and I am at my home office. So sorry

[Jveggy]

I have exactly the same issues with the v5.13,  is is possible to make previous versions available to (5.9 I understand works fine) 

[yunmi23]

My situation is that I got a new computer running Windows 11 and all of a sudden "original sound for musicians" was not working despite ticking all the correct settings in Zoom. People could hear my voice but not my instrument at all.

I did 2 things and it solved the issue:

1) In Zoom advanced audio settings I ticked "OFF" for signal processing for windows audio driver

2) This solution is cut and paste from another forum:

I managed to solve my issue by following the instructions found in another thread (see below). I searched for MaxxAudioPro on my computer (similarly didn't know I had it...). Seems somewhat strange for this to have been the problem, but holding thumbs that it isn't just a stroke of luck but solved. Worth a try!

Suggestion is to - and I quote - 

"I had a similar issue that was resolved by a community member. In the MaxxAudioPro Waves app (I didn't know I had this), choose the icon/tab for voice (in the upper right, looks like a top down view of a person at a computer). Turn/toggle off the button on the left below the tab icons (terrible UI) and that's it!" - so, then the "soundwaves" screen thingy underneath is turned off.

[JosefineR]

Unfortunately MaxxAudioPro was not installed on my computer at all, at least I could not find it by searching for installed apps, so I could not entirely try your suggestion.

[Farkel]

I bought a brand new laptop with Windows 11 and zoom installed in a church environment with an organ. When I set the "original Sound For Musicians"  to do my zoom recording I can hear the pastor speak but when the service switches to the organ playing I don't hear a thing. So after reading multiple people complain about this issue and looked at the solutions offered I decided to go back to Windows 10 which I have now done. Thinking this would fix the problem I retested everything and it still did not work. My version of zoom is 15.13.11 and I have windows 10 installed with all of the latest updates applied,  I'm receiving complaints from my parishioners every week about not being able to hear the organ and I'm getting tired of it. Is there someone at Zoom that can help me with this problem please?????

[Farkel]

Well I've now put an older version of Zoom on my computer to match an older computer that is working with the "original sound for musicians". That means I'm now on Windows 10 using zoom version 5.13.3 and I still have no sound from the organ. I can hear myself speak (so the microphone is working) but the moment the organ begins to play I don't hear it. If I talk while the organ is playing I can still hear myself speak without a problem. Still waiting for someone to let me know if they have a solution to this issue. Please help.

[Farkel]

Well I finally got the organ to be heard on Zoom. What I had to do was take a 3 year old Dell laptop and ensure that it was running Windows 10 (latest version) and Zoom (latest version) and it worked perfectly. I believe now that through all my tests there is an issue with either Zoom and Windows 11 or Zoom and the latest computer chips. How I came to this conclusion is that I had a brand new HP Laptop and downgraded it to Windows 10 and even downgraded and upgraded Zoom version without any luck. As soon as I moved back to my old Dell laptop and ensured I had windows 10 and the latest version of Zoom running (in effect the same versions as the HP computer) it worked perfectly.  Go figure??

[storyhub]

Nice to hear you found a solution that appears to work. However, your issue is more related to the hardware than Windows 11 or Zoom. As a broadcast engineer I can tell you that audio can be very complicated on computers, especially when trying to use the onboard hardware. That is why we always use outboard sound cards or audio interfaces connected via USB, which are highly reliable.

[DougD]

In Zoom audio settings, on the advanced page, set the Signal processing by Windows audio device drivers to OFF.  That fixed the problem for me, at least.