Zoom Screen Share + Voicemeeter Potato = No Audio For Screen Sharing

Hello.

I have a dual PC streaming setup where I'm sending audio split up in Voicemeeter Potato on my gaming PC to my streaming PC. Whenever I'm in Zoom and screen sharing in a meeting, I can share my screen but the audio doesn't work.

My audio input in Zoom is set to my Microphone (B3), and my audio output is set to Voicemeeter Input. The only way that I seem to share audio with my screen is if I add the audio to B3 as well, but this will cause the mic audio as well to send to the streaming PC.

Shouldn't the audio from my PC come from the audio output in Zoom and not the audio input?