Music not recording well

I am using a Yeti Blue microphone in a chapel. The mic is on the altar, and picks up spoken vocals just fine. But when the piano (10 feet away) is used—regardless of the settings on the mic—the music (and congregational singing) simply cuts out; the sound is similar to a guitar string being plucked, and then silenced. 

I've tried some of the advanced audio settings (such as original sound for musicians), but nothing seems to change the music sound going out.

I'm using Mac OS Big Sur 11.6.8, and the latest Zoom client.