OK so it took me all day to figure this out...
Problem: Firmware was not up to date causing the display issue on recently added phones.
Problem: Could not update firmware via Web interface because ZOOM automatically disables it after a phone is provisioned.
Solution: Turned Web Interface On in Zoom, reset phones to factory, accessed the GUI, updated firmware and did Assisted Provisioning.
Unfortunately the existing phones did not take the update/reboot well for the Web Interface being turned on, so I have to factory reset them and repeat the process for the 4 other phones.
Firmware update solved the bug in the phones and I am able to access the web GUI after enabling it and resetting and reprovisioning phones.
Thank you guys for your help!